These Job Titles Didn’t Exist Two Years Ago. Here’s What That Means If You Work in Search.

Our data piece on the Future of Search found that 20.3% of SEO job postings now mention AI search, GEO, or AEO skills, up from 12.2% in December 2025.

That’s a fast number for a job market to move.
But the more convincing evidence didn’t come from just the data alone. We went a layer deeper from that with the three experts who sat down with to talk about it.

None of their titles would have made sense on a business card two years ago.

One is running AI search across two multi-billion dollar brands from a single seat. One had a title change mid-year that our host called out live on the call. One is in the middle of building the framework that will eventually become her teams’ title change. If you want to know where search is actually heading, read their titles before you read another stat.

Andrew Prince: one seat, two brands, a role that didn’t exist a year ago

Andrew Prince is Head of AI Search at both Redfin and Rocket, with visibility into Rocket Loans, Rocket Money, and Rent.com as well. That’s not a job description that existed as a single seat a couple of years ago. It’s what happens when a company decides AI visibility is important enough to consolidate under one owner instead of leaving it scattered across separate SEO teams per brand.

He put a number on the shift himself later in the session: his job has changed more in the last year than in the years before it, moving from being “an SEO at Rocket” to owning AI search across the entire portfolio. Not having to weigh keyword targeting or legacy link-building in the same way anymore is, in his words, what makes the new version of the job genuinely different from the old one, not just a rebrand of it.

Two things stood out about how he’s actually running the role, beyond the title itself:

A three-question framework for explaining it upward. Rather than talking crawl budgets to executives, he distilled the entire discipline into three questions: are we findable by LLMs, are we showing up in prompts, and are we showing up favorably. That last one is the one most people skip. He described a case where Rocket Mortgage appeared in an AI answer, but the framing was bad enough that it would have been better not to appear at all. Visibility without accuracy can actively work against a brand, which is a distinction a raw “are we mentioned” metric will never catch.

A cross-functional network instead of a bigger team. He’s built what he calls AI search champions across Redfin and Rocket, volunteers from PR, affiliate, product, tech, and video who each give a few hours a month to carry best practices back into their own teams. It’s the same logic that’s always separated strong SEOs from average ones, that the job isn’t doing everything yourself inside a platform, it’s getting ten other people across the business to factor it into their day-to-day work. He’s just running that playbook at AI search speed now.

There’s a smaller, sharper moment worth pulling out too. He ran his own LinkedIn profile through ChatGPT and asked it to summarize his role. It came back with “growth and discovery,” language he hadn’t fed it directly. Even the models are already describing this work in the new vocabulary before most job boards have caught up.

When asked what he’s actually hiring for now, his answer skipped hard skills entirely: critical thinking and the ability to prioritize. In a regulated, enterprise-scale environment there are dozens of things worth testing at any given time and only room to do a handful of them, so knowing what’s actually worth the time matters more than knowing everything.

Amir Alsayegh: when a title change is the actual data point

Amir’s title is Global AEO/SEO-GEO Team Lead at Crocs. Worth sitting with that for a second, because our host called it out directly on the panel: he’d had a title change to AEO/GEO within the past year, on top of his existing focus on international SEO and cultural nuance across regions.

A title change isn’t a company following a trend. It’s a company deciding a function is now distinct enough, and permanent enough, to warrant its own name and its own mandate on an org chart. Titles are usually a lagging indicator in a business. When they move this fast, the underlying work moved first and leadership is just catching up to it.

His international focus made him the panel’s sharpest voice on a point that gets skipped in most US and UK-led search conversations: optimizing for Western LLMs can make a brand invisible everywhere else. South Korea runs largely on Naver, with its own conversational AI layered into social commerce. Japan runs its own AI integration through Yahoo, on a different rule set than Google’s AI overviews. In parts of Latin America and Asia, WhatsApp functions almost agentically, surfacing products directly in chat and letting people buy there. His conclusion: there’s a maturity gap between what companies assume the rest of the world is doing and what’s actually happening, and treating it as the same rollout on a delay rather than a genuinely different consumer behavior is a real strategic error.

Inside Crocs, that international lens has reshaped what even gets measured. His clearest line of the session: a brand site used to be the destination, now it’s changed into the asset, one of several sources platforms pull from to build an answer that gets delivered somewhere else entirely. The team is moving away from site sessions and click-through rate as headline numbers, toward share of model, brand sentiment, and whether an interaction left someone with a genuinely good impression, regardless of which platform it happened on. He tied it back to a line their own CEO gave internally when asked what the preferred channel for reaching customers was: “meet them where they want to be met.” Not where it’s easiest to track them.

On hiring, he was the most direct panelist of the three: “skills are almost going away.” He said he doesn’t care how much keyword research a candidate has done or how many articles they’ve optimized. What he’s actually screening for is curiosity, specifically whether someone has the investigative instinct to go figure out how something works without being told to.

He also had the most pointed take on language itself. Asked about a LinkedIn post where he’d needled people for saying “SEO optimized,” he explained he now deliberately calls the whole discipline “AI search” internally, not AEO, not GEO, not LLM optimization, because the people he needs buy-in from (branding teams, customer service, product) don’t know or care about internal SEO jargon. “GEO” reads to most non-specialists as a geography campaign. “AI search” is the only version of the name that actually travels across a whole organization, which matters more than getting the taxonomy exactly right among peers.

Sophie Brannon: on why their team are looking into re-titling themselves

Sophie Brannon is co-founder and Director of Ops at StudioHawk US, based in Atlanta. The fuller bio is where it gets interesting: industry awards judge, frequent conference speaker, and now search engine journalist, on top of running the agency side of the business. That range isn’t a resume that happened to accumulate. It reflects something specific about where search authority comes from right now: nobody trusts a single-channel specialist as the last word anymore, not clients, not AI platforms building “share of model,” not the industry itself.

What makes her the most interesting case study of the three is that her title hasn’t caught up to her work yet, and she said so herself. StudioHawk is building an entire new framework (a book, a webinar series, a rollout starting in the US before other regions) organized around making brands discoverable in AI search, not just Google and Bing. Internally, the phrase “we’re now discoverability experts” has already stuck. It’s not a formal title change yet. But it’s the exact same shift Amir’s title already went through, just one step earlier in the process, which makes the two of them a genuinely useful before-and-after on the same panel.

That reframe came out of a real business problem, not a branding exercise. She described losing clients late last year and into this one because a CEO saw a “SEO is dead” post on LinkedIn and wouldn’t take a call. “Discoverability” became the reframe that let her team open a conversation without immediately fighting a narrative that had already lost the room. It also happens to describe the work more accurately: as she put it later, performance marketing has spent years talking about “SEO users” and “paid social users” as if they’re different people, when they’re the same user in different parts of the same funnel. The old channel-specific language was never really accurate. AI search just made the gap impossible to ignore.

Under that framework, StudioHawk has rebuilt its own three pillars. It used to be technical SEO, backlinks, and content. Now it’s structure and crawlability, genuine off-site presence across every platform actually being cited (not just backlinks and brand mentions), and real differentiation, the kind that isn’t just the same generic USP every competitor in the category also claims. She runs a regional version of Andrew’s champions model too: Charlie in the US, Lorcan in the UK, and Ferg leading an AI enablement team in Australia, each translating new workflows back to their own teams because, as she put it, not everyone has the time or the technical appetite to build the tooling themselves.

Her hiring answer led with hunger to learn, specifically the difference between passively consuming SEO content (webinars, newsletters, search engine journal alerts) and actually getting hands-on inside a tool like Claude to find something broken and fix it. She said it applies at any seniority level, junior or senior, and it’s what separates candidates who’ll keep up with the pace of change from ones who won’t.

Her closing advice doubled as the panel’s clearest warning: “the loudest tactics are not the best tactics.” Any confident LinkedIn post claiming there’s one tactic that guarantees AI search visibility (Reddit is everything, listicles are the answer, whatever the current version is) is wrong by definition. AI visibility runs on a system with roughly as many variables as a Google algorithm, not a single lever.

What their titles tell you that the data can’t

Put together, three distinct patterns show up that a stats page won’t give you on its own:

  • Consolidation. Andrew’s single seat covering multiple brands is a company betting that AI visibility needs one owner, not five disconnected teams each doing their own version of it.
  • Formalization, already done. Amir’s title change is a company deciding this is a permanent discipline, not a temporary initiative someone’s doing on the side of their actual job.
  • Formalization, in progress. Sophie’s “discoverability experts” language, book, and webinar series show the exact same shift happening at agency level, one step behind Amir’s on the timeline, which is a useful preview of where a lot of other companies are about to land.

That 20.3% of postings mentioning these skills isn’t describing a future trend. It’s describing what already happened to these three roles, and what’s now happening at the level below them as companies build out the rest of the team around them.

What this means if you’re building a search career, or building the team around one

If you’re on the candidate side: none of the people getting hired into these roles are winning on years of keyword research. All three panelists said some version of the same thing independently, that curiosity, critical thinking, and the willingness to own a function nobody’s fully defined yet matter more than a resume full of past tactics. The skill isn’t knowing SEO. It’s the investigative instinct to figure out whatever comes next without being told to.

If you’re on the hiring side: waiting for a settled job title before you create the role is how you end up a year behind a company that already consolidated theirs. Amir’s title didn’t change because Crocs found the perfect name for it, it changed because the work had already outgrown the old one. Sophie’s team is proof that the same shift is coming for a lot of other organizations that haven’t made it formal yet. The title lags. The work doesn’t wait for it.

Watch the full panel, including the parts we didn’t cover here, on YouTube.

Frequently asked questions

Is SEO actually dying because of AI search?

No, according to all three panelists. Andrew’s view was the most direct: SEO isn’t becoming less important, it’s becoming more important, because the pool of people who still click through is smaller but carries higher intent than before. Amir and Sophie both framed the current moment as a change in the discipline’s shape, not its relevance.

Why did Amir’s title change to AEO/GEO?

It wasn’t addressed directly as a single cause on the panel, but the pattern across his and Sophie’s answers points to the same driver: the work (international AI visibility, cross-platform brand presence, cultural nuance across regions) had already grown past what a traditional international SEO title covered, and the title changed to reflect the mandate that already existed.

What should search marketers actually be learning right now?

Less about mastering a specific tool and more about curiosity and critical thinking. Amir said he no longer weighs keyword research experience heavily when hiring. Sophie’s version was “hunger to learn,” specifically the willingness to get hands-on with a tool like Claude and fix a broken process, at any seniority level. Andrew’s answer centered on critical thinking and prioritization, since there are more things worth testing than time to test them.

Is it a mistake to optimize only for ChatGPT or Google AI overviews?

Yes, if a brand operates internationally. Amir’s data point: South Korea runs largely on Naver, Japan runs its own AI layer through Yahoo, and parts of Latin America and Asia use WhatsApp as an agentic shopping interface. Optimizing exclusively for Western LLMs can make a brand effectively invisible in markets that never adopted those platforms the same way.

What’s the difference between SEO, AEO, and GEO, and does it actually matter which term you use?

Functionally, the three terms describe overlapping work: making a brand findable, whether that’s in a search engine’s blue links or in an AI-generated answer. What matters more than the taxonomy, according to Amir, is which term your internal audience actually understands. He deliberately uses “AI search” internally at Crocs rather than AEO or GEO, because teams outside SEO (branding, customer service, product) read “GEO” as a geography campaign rather than a discipline.

How are companies measuring AI search performance differently than traditional SEO?

Amir described Crocs’ shift away from site sessions and click-through rate as headline metrics, toward share of model, brand sentiment, and whether an interaction left someone with a good impression of the brand, regardless of which platform it happened on. Andrew’s version was a three-question framework: are we findable by LLMs, are we showing up in prompts, and are we showing up favorably, since visibility without accuracy can hurt a brand more than not showing up at all.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between AEO, GEO, and AIO, and does it actually matter which term you use?

Honestly, not much, and all three guests said as much. AEO (Answer Engine Optimisation), GEO (Generative Engine Optimisation), and AIO (AI Optimisation) are all describing the same shift: search is increasingly being answered by AI platforms rather than a list of blue links. The terminology is still settling across the industry. What matters more than the label is what you're actually doing about it, and right now, the fundamentals of good SEO are the same fundamentals that get you cited by AI platforms.

Should I optimise for AI search before sorting out my SEO fundamentals?

No, and this was the strongest point of agreement across the episode. Anthony from StudioHawk described it as clients "asking for a Ferrari when they need a Toyota." If your website is technically weak, your content is thin, or you have no link authority, optimising for ChatGPT or Perplexity visibility won't move the needle. The agencies seeing results with AI search are the ones who treated it as the cherry on top of a well-built SEO foundation, not the other way around.

Are AI overviews a threat to organic search traffic?

All three guests called it an opportunity, not a threat. AI overviews sit at the top of the organic SERP, they're the first thing a user sees after paid ads. For agencies that learn how to structure content that gets cited in them, it's the biggest piece of SERP real estate available right now. Charlie's view: it's about producing content in a way that speaks to user intent and earns inclusion. That skill is worth building now, not later.

How should agencies be talking to clients about the decline in click volume?

By shifting the metric from traffic to revenue. Click volume is declining across the industry, that's not a forecast, it's already happening. The agencies navigating this best are the ones who repositioned SEO as a commercial driver rather than a traffic play. As Charlie put it, "SEO is now being sold as what it was supposed to be sold as, a revenue-driving practice." Customers aren't going to say no to more revenue. They will push back on a traffic report that's trending down.

How does personalised search change the way we produce content?

Significantly. Anthony made the point that two people searching for the same thing, say, a pair of shoes, may get completely different results based on their browser history, past behaviour, and query phrasing. That means targeting a single keyword is becoming less reliable. What works instead is content that gives Google and LLMs enough context to match it to a wide range of query variants: who the product is for, who it isn't for, what problem it solves, and why it's the best answer. Context-rich content wins over keyword-stuffed content in a personalised search world.

What hard skills are SEO agencies prioritising in hires right now?

The conversation has moved away from static technical checklists. Given how fast the landscape is shifting, new model releases, Google updates, AI platform changes, specific hard skills have a shorter shelf life than they did two or three years ago. What all three guests converged on was the ability to learn quickly and repeatedly. That said, technical SEO foundations remain important, and any demonstrated experience with AI tools, prompt engineering, or building things (even side projects) is a strong signal. The hard skill that's lost relevance fastest is rote keyword research, the kind that doesn't require judgement.

What should agencies look for when hiring junior SEOs who have no prior experience?

Evidence of the learning pattern, applied to anything. Anthony's framing was clear: past behaviour is the best indicator of future behaviour. If a junior candidate has built a website, run a side project, completed relevant coursework on their own time, or developed a genuine expertise in any area, that shows the drive and initiative that transfers into SEO. It doesn't need to be polished or finished. It just needs to demonstrate that they've committed to learning something outside of what was required of them.

Why is cultural fit being weighted so heavily in agency hiring right now?

Because the pace of change means no static skill set stays current for long. Charlie put it directly, a new Claude release or a major model update can shift best practice overnight. In that environment, what matters most is whether someone has the curiosity and adaptability to keep learning. Cultural fit, in this context, isn't about personality match for its own sake. It's a proxy for whether someone will thrive in a fast-moving environment, take ownership, and stay engaged when the playbook changes underneath them.

Find Your Next Search Marketer

With 95% of roles filled within 25 days, our approach is built for pace and backed by a 1 year guarantee.

Contact

Related Posts