Guest: Graham Grieve
Graham Grieve rebuilt A1 SEO as Peak Visibility, a brand made for search and AI together. He told Josh Peacock why the old SEO name could not carry AI search, CRO and digital PR, how he kept the old domains working, and why buyers now come in asking for GEO instead of SEO. He also explains why a £100K upfront sprint is easier to close than a £10K a month retainer, and how he got his team using AI without replacing anyone.
• Selling a GEO offer under an old SEO brand can sound like the same agency with a new acronym.
• He did 90% of the rebrand in Claude, then briefed a designer to take what they had and make it cool.
• A £10,000 a month retainer gets a no; the same work as a £100K upfront sprint gets a yes.
Pulled from a full transcript of the published cut, matched to where each topic starts.
The episode opens on Graham’s blunt take: selling a new AI offer under the old brand “just sounded like another greasy SEO agency trying to now sell GEO.” That is the risk for any agency adding a new service. Buyers hear the name first and the offer second, so a new acronym under an old SEO name can sound like the same agency trying something new.
Josh takes it back to 2021, when Graham came on the original podcast, then called Diary of an SEO. A lot has changed since then, including the show, and Josh uses that catch-up to get into the rebrand.
Josh still knew Graham as A1 SEO. Earlier this year he rebranded to Peak Visibility. The old name could not hold AI search, CRO and digital PR. Peak Visibility was built as an umbrella brand so those services could sit together, which A1 SEO could not do.
Actionable advice: If you are adding a service line, ask whether your name can hold more than one thing. If it describes a single service, it will keep pulling buyers back to that service.
“We did 90% of the rebrand in Claude,” Graham says, then they passed it to a brand designer. The brief was simple: this is what we came up with, we need you to tweak it to make it cool. A lot more went into it than he expected, including culture, values and vision, and it was also easier than he expected.
Josh asks whether there was a site migration. Graham says they still have A1 SEO, A1 SEO Glasgow and A1 SEO Edinburgh sitting there, because they rank well. Peak Visibility has its own SEO strategy, so they launched it as a new website. They will probably migrate the main A1 SEO domain later, but he wants to keep the Glasgow and Edinburgh sites as two standalone lead-gen properties for now.
Actionable advice: List what already brings in leads before you change anything. Domains, ads, people. Keep them working while the new brand builds.
The conversation moves on to whether AI search is the biggest change in a decade, and what that means for an agency that has just put a new brand around search and AI together. Add the verified timestamp here once captions cover this section.
Buyers who used to come in asking for SEO now come in asking for GEO. Graham’s view is that the work is not a completely different service. GEO, or AI search, is work designed to help a brand show up in AI answers and generative search as well as classic Google results. It is close to SEO. But buyers now arrive through a different door, and you have to meet them there.
A £10,000 a month retainer gets a no. The same work as a £100K upfront sprint gets a yes. A sprint is a scoped piece of work paid upfront, and Graham is finding sprints easier to close right now, even when the total is similar.
Peak Visibility does not sell SEO or GEO as separate lines. They take on visibility clients who want to appear in search engines and in AI.
The biggest change in how they pitch over the last two years is selling the outcome, not the deliverable. Outcome-based selling means pitching the result the client wants, like leads, revenue or visibility, rather than a list of pages, links and reports.
Actionable advice:
Outcomes only work if you can prove them. They have always asked whether the phone is ringing. They use WhatConverts, Stape, Triple Whale and Shopify reporting, because GA4 often misattributes SEO as direct or paid.
Everyone at Peak Visibility got a Claude license in February. They were offered a cash bonus for automating 40 hours or more. And they were promised that nobody gets replaced by AI.
They built software trained on their own writing to break the AI language pattern. Clients can now choose between 10 human pages or 100 AI-edited ones, on the same budget.
At the end of 2023 and the start of 2024, funding was tight. The offers Graham saw for agencies like his were around a 3x multiple, paid over three years, with working capital and tax due on day one. In his example, it was better to hold the agency, keep the asset, and earn the same money faster.
They run EOS, the Entrepreneurial Operating System, and keep more than 400 video SOPs up to date. Graham says he now works on Peak Visibility maybe three hours a day. (In the opening hook he also puts it as two, maybe three hours a day.)
Six months of Instagram has not done much on its own yet, so he is treating personal brand as a three-to-five-year play. Near term, that organic content goes into tightly targeted “omnipresent” Meta awareness ads. Paid Meta is already one of their biggest acquisition channels, and Graham says people recognize his face in the ads more than the name, which made the rebrand smoother.
Graham’s view of the job now is making brands digestible for algorithms, and that teams who can feed those algorithms what they want will have an edge in commerce.

He built Peak Visibility as an umbrella brand after an AI offer under A1 SEO started to sound greasy.
No. The A1 SEO sites still rank, so Peak Visibility is a new site. City sites stay as lead-gen properties.
Yes. At 4:22 Graham says they did 90% in Claude, then briefed a designer to make it cool. It covered culture, values and vision, not just a logo.
A £10,000 a month retainer gets a no; a £100K sprint gets a yes. Sprints are easier to close, and he now sells the outcome, not the deliverable.
The team got Claude, a 40-hour automation bonus, and a promise nobody is replaced. Clients can buy 10 human pages or 100 AI-edited ones.
Funding was tight in late 2023 and early 2024. 3x offers paid over three years, with tax due on day one, made it better to keep the agency.
With 95% of roles filled within 28 days, our approach is built for pace and backed by a 1 year guarantee. Get access to the systems and frameworks that power elite SFH teams.